Brandy vs Cognac
Cognac is a kind of brandy, the way Champagne is a kind of sparkling wine. Brandy is any spirit distilled from fermented fruit, and in the US the plain word means grape brandy. Cognac is grape brandy from one region of western France, made under rules that fix the grapes, the still, the minimum age and what may be added. A shot of either has the same 98 calories from alcohol at 40%; the sugar Vinmonopolet measured ran from under 3 to 25 grams per liter, and the sweetest bottles were Spanish brandy, not cognac.
Is cognac brandy?
Yes. All cognac is brandy, and most brandy is not cognac. US rules define cognac as grape brandy distilled only in the Cognac region of France under French law, and French rules require it to be made there from wine of listed white grapes, mostly Ugni Blanc. Hennessy, Martell, Rémy Martin and Courvoisier are all brandy for that reason.
What is the difference between brandy and cognac?
Place and rules. Brandy can be made anywhere from any fruit; only grape brandy may be called just "brandy" in the US. Cognac must come from the Cognac region (Charente, Charente-Maritime and a few communes of Dordogne and Deux-Sèvres), be distilled twice in a copper Charentais pot still to no more than 73.7%, spend at least 2 years in oak and be sold at 40% or stronger. EU brandy needs only 6 months in small oak casks and 36% alcohol.
Which has more calories or sugar?
About the same. A 1.5 oz pour at 40% carries 14 g of alcohol, 98 calories, whichever it is. The 14 cognacs we found measured 4 to 11 g of sugar per liter, about 0.4 g a shot at the median. The Spanish brandies ran 12 to 25 g per liter, still only 1.1 g a shot at the top. Several European brandies are bottled at 38%, which makes them slightly lighter: 93 calories from the alcohol.
Brandy vs Cognac: the differences
| Attribute | Brandy | Cognac |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A spirit distilled from fermented fruit juice, mash or wine, or what is left after pressing | Grape brandy from one region of France, made to its AOC rules |
| Where | Anywhere. Some names belong to one place: Armagnac, Brandy de Jerez, Calvados, Pisco | Charente, Charente-Maritime and a few communes of Dordogne and Deux-Sèvres |
| Made from | Grapes when the label just says brandy (US); other fruit must be named, as in apple brandy | Wine of Ugni Blanc, Colombard, Folle Blanche, Montils or Sémillon grapes, 7 to 12% alcohol, with no enrichment (added sugar or concentrate) allowed |
| Still | Any. Distilled below 95% (US) or 86% for EU wine spirit | Copper Charentais pot still, twice, to 73.7% at most |
| Aging | US: 2 years in oak, or the label must say immature. EU: 6 months in casks under 1,000 L or 1 year in larger oak | At least 2 years in oak, in the region. VSOP 4, XO 10 |
| Strength | At least 40% (US), 36% (EU) | At least 40% |
| May add | EU: caramel for color and up to 35 g of sweetening per liter | Caramel, sweetening and boisé (an oak chip infusion), within a 4% vol limit |
| Methanol cap | EU: 200 mg per 100 mL of pure alcohol (1,000 for grappa) | Under 100 mg per 100 mL of pure alcohol |
| Sugar measured | Under 3 to 25 g/L in 8 bottles | 4 to 11 g/L in 14 bottles |
| 1.5 oz at 40% | 98 calories from alcohol, plus up to 4 from sugar | 98 calories from alcohol, plus about 2 from sugar |
| Gluten | Made from fruit, no gluten grains | Made from grapes, no gluten grains |
| Hangover Index | Not rated as one group: it depends on the type | 8/10 |
Cognac
White wine, distilled twice in copper, aged in oak
- Congeners
- High
- Histamines
- Low
- Polyphenols
- Moderate
- Sulfites
- Low
- Tannins
- Moderate
- Sugar
- Moderate
- Additives
- Moderate
Cognac is a brandy with stricter rules, not a different drink. It is the safer bet if you want a known still, a 2-year minimum and an age term that means something on the label; for calories and sugar the gap is a rounding error, and the sweetest bottles we found were Spanish brandies, not cognac.
Is cognac brandy? The types of brandy
US rules define brandy as a spirit distilled from the fermented juice, mash or wine of fruit, or from what is left of it, at under 95% alcohol and bottled at 40% or more. The plain word "brandy" is reserved for grape brandy; one made from another fruit has to name it, as apple brandy or cherry brandy do. Several types are tied to a place and to that country's own rules, and cognac is one of them.
So Hennessy is cognac, and therefore brandy. So is every Martell, Rémy Martin and Courvoisier. The reverse does not hold: a California or Spanish grape brandy is brandy but can never be cognac, whatever its age or price.
| Type | Made from | Where (US rule) |
|---|---|---|
| Brandy, grape brandy | Grape wine | Anywhere |
| Cognac | Grape wine | Only the Cognac region of France, under French law |
| Armagnac | Grape wine | Only France, under the rules for Armagnac |
| Brandy de Jerez | Grape wine | Only Spain, under the rules for Brandy de Jerez |
| Pisco | Grapes | Only Peru or Chile, under that country's rules |
| Singani | Grapes | Only Bolivia |
| Calvados | Apples | Only France, under the rules for Calvados |
| Apple brandy, applejack | Apples | Anywhere |
| Kirschwasser, slivovitz | Cherries, plums | Anywhere |
| Grappa, pomace or marc brandy | Grape skins and pulp left after pressing | Anywhere |
Source: 27 CFR 5.145. A grape brandy aged under 2 years in oak must be labeled immature brandy in the US.
What makes a brandy cognac
The Cognac appellation's rules start in the vineyard. The wine must come from Ugni Blanc, Colombard, Folle Blanche, Montils or Sémillon grapes, with Folignan allowed up to 10% of the planting, and Ugni Blanc is by far the most planted. No sugar may be added to raise its strength, no sulfur dioxide may be used while it ferments, and it must be 7 to 12% alcohol when it goes into the still.
The still is fixed too: a copper Charentais alembic, run twice. The first distillation turns the wine into a brouillis; the second, the bonne chauffe, makes the eau-de-vie, at no more than 73.7% alcohol, and all of it must be done by March 31 after the harvest. The spirit then ages only in oak, for at least 2 years, inside the region.
Finishing is limited to three things: caramel for color, sweetening to round off the taste, and an infusion of oak chips in hot water called boisé. Together they may lower the apparent strength by no more than 4% vol (the obscuration). The bottle must be at least 40%, with no more than 100 mg of methanol per 100 mL of pure alcohol. US rules mirror the additive list: anything other than caramel, oak chip infusion and sugar added to cognac forces a different name on the label.
Age terms count the youngest spirit in the blend: VS (Very Special) at least 2 years, VSOP (Very Superior Old Pale, Réserve) at least 4 years, XO (Extra Old, Hors d'âge) at least 10 years, XXO (Extra Extra Old) at least 14 years. Other brandy has no shared scale. In the EU, brandy must spend 6 months in oak casks under 1,000 liters or a year in larger ones; in the US, grape brandy under 2 years in oak must say "immature" on the label.
Sugar in 22 brandies and cognacs, measured
Neither label lists sugar, so we used Norway's state retailer, Vinmonopolet, which publishes a measured figure for each bottle it sells. The 14 cognacs ran from 4 to 11 g per liter, median 8.5: Hennessy VS at 4, Hennessy VSOP at 9.8 and Hennessy XO at 10.1. The sweetest of the 22 was Lustau Solera Gran Reserva, a Brandy de Jerez, at 25 g. An unaged Blanche d'Armagnac, a German Asbach and a Chilean pisco were under 3.
That is less than it sounds. Even 25 g per liter is 1.1 g in a 1.5 oz pour, about 4 calories on top of the 98 from alcohol. The EU cap for brandy, 35 g per liter, would be 1.6 g.
| Bottle | ABV | Sugar g/L | Sugar 1.5 oz | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cognac (14) | ||||
| Hennessy VS | 40% | 4 | 0.2 g | 99 |
| Rémy Martin 1738 Accord Royal | 40% | 4 | 0.2 g | 99 |
| Rémy Martin Louis XIII | 40% | 5 | 0.2 g | 99 |
| Martell VSOP | 40% | 5.5 | 0.2 g | 99 |
| Martell VS | 40% | 6 | 0.3 g | 99 |
| Hine Rare VSOP | 40% | 8 | 0.4 g | 99 |
| Martell Cordon Bleu | 40% | 8 | 0.4 g | 99 |
| Rémy Martin VSOP | 40% | 8.9 | 0.4 g | 100 |
| Braastad Extra | 40% | 9 | 0.4 g | 100 |
| Hennessy VSOP | 40% | 9.8 | 0.4 g | 100 |
| Baron Otard VSOP | 40% | 10 | 0.4 g | 100 |
| Hennessy Paradis | 40% | 10 | 0.4 g | 100 |
| Hennessy XO | 40% | 10.1 | 0.4 g | 100 |
| Frapin VSOP | 40% | 11 | 0.5 g | 100 |
| Armagnac | ||||
| Delord Blanche d'Armagnac | 42% | Under 3 | 0.1 g | 103 |
| Dartigalongue Bas Armagnac VSOP | 42% | 6 | 0.3 g | 104 |
| Spanish brandy | ||||
| Carlos I | 40% | 12 | 0.5 g | 100 |
| Lustau Solera Gran Reserva | 40% | 25 | 1.1 g | 102 |
| Torres 10 Imperial Gran Reserva | 38% | 12 | 0.5 g | 95 |
| Other brandy and pisco | ||||
| Asbach Original 3 Years | 38% | Under 3 | 0.1 g | 94 |
| Vecchia Romagna Etichetta Nera | 38% | 8 | 0.4 g | 95 |
| Torres Pisco El Gobernador | 40% | Under 3 | 0.1 g | 99 |
Sugar as measured by Vinmonopolet ("under 3 g/L" counted as 3). Calories for a 1.5 oz pour: 7 per gram of alcohol, 4 per gram of sugar.
Calories in brandy and cognac
Almost all of the calories are alcohol. At 40% a 1.5 oz pour holds 14 g of it, one US standard drink, and 98 calories, the same as vodka, whiskey or rum at that strength. Measured sugar adds under 1 to about 4 more. The bigger lever is strength: the 38% brandies (Torres 10, Vecchia Romagna, Asbach) have 93 calories from alcohol, 94 to 95 with their sugar.
The glass matters more than the bottle. In eggnog the brandy is the smaller part of the calories, and a hot toddy gets most of its sugar from the honey. Cognac rankings by calories and congeners are on healthiest cognac, and the other holiday drinks are on Christmas cocktails.
Does brandy or cognac give a worse hangover?
We found no study comparing cognac with other brandy. Brandy as a whole is among the drinks linked to worse hangovers: in the classic comparisons summarized for NIAAA, purer drinks like vodka and gin caused fewer hangover effects than whiskey, brandy or red wine. The difference is congeners, the byproducts that give an aged spirit its taste. In a Brown University trial that took 95 young heavy drinkers to the same breath alcohol level on bourbon or on vodka, the authors concluded that ethanol is the main cause of hangover and congeners may add to its severity.
Methanol is the congener the law caps. Per US standard drink, cognac's limit works out to about 17.7 mg, EU brandy's to 35.5 and grappa's to 177.4, against 1.8 for EU vodka. These are ceilings, not measurements, but they show which way each style leans. In one small study of four people, methanol took about 2 to 3.5 hours to halve once ethanol was nearly gone, and its washout lined up with the start of the hangover. More on congeners, how long a hangover lasts and what helps.
The most reliable way to a better morning is less of either: sip it, eat, and drink water between glasses.
Which one for which situation
FAQ
Is cognac brandy? ▾
Yes. All cognac is brandy, and most brandy is not cognac. US rules define cognac as grape brandy distilled only in the Cognac region of France under French law, and French rules require it to be made there from wine of listed white grapes, mostly Ugni Blanc. Hennessy, Martell, Rémy Martin and Courvoisier are all brandy for that reason.
What is the difference between brandy and cognac? ▾
Place and rules. Brandy can be made anywhere from any fruit; only grape brandy may be called just "brandy" in the US. Cognac must come from the Cognac region (Charente, Charente-Maritime and a few communes of Dordogne and Deux-Sèvres), be distilled twice in a copper Charentais pot still to no more than 73.7%, spend at least 2 years in oak and be sold at 40% or stronger. EU brandy needs only 6 months in small oak casks and 36% alcohol.
Which has more calories or sugar? ▾
About the same. A 1.5 oz pour at 40% carries 14 g of alcohol, 98 calories, whichever it is. The 14 cognacs we found measured 4 to 11 g of sugar per liter, about 0.4 g a shot at the median. The Spanish brandies ran 12 to 25 g per liter, still only 1.1 g a shot at the top. Several European brandies are bottled at 38%, which makes them slightly lighter: 93 calories from the alcohol.
Is Hennessy brandy or cognac? ▾
Both. Hennessy is cognac, and all cognac is grape brandy. Hennessy VS measured 4 g of sugar per liter at Vinmonopolet, about 0.2 g in a 1.5 oz pour. See Hennessy VS.
Is cognac whiskey? ▾
No. Whiskey is distilled from a fermented mash of grain; cognac is distilled from wine. Both age in oak, which gives them a similar color, but they belong to different families. See cognac vs bourbon.
What is the difference between brandy and whiskey? ▾
What is fermented. Brandy comes from fruit, usually grape wine; whiskey from grain such as corn, barley, rye or wheat. US rules put both below 95% alcohol off the still and at 40% or more in the bottle, so at 40% a 1.5 oz shot of either has about 98 calories.
What is brandy made from? ▾
Fermented fruit. Plain "brandy" is made from grape wine; apple brandy, cherry brandy (kirschwasser) and plum brandy (slivovitz) name their fruit, and grappa or marc is made from the skins and pulp left after pressing grapes.
What do VS, VSOP and XO mean on cognac? ▾
The age of the youngest spirit in the blend. VS (Very Special) is at least 2 years in oak, VSOP (Very Superior Old Pale) at least 4, XO (Extra Old) at least 10, and XXO at least 14. These are Cognac's definitions; other brandies that use the letters follow their own region's rules.
Is cognac stronger than brandy? ▾
Sometimes, slightly. Cognac must be at least 40%, as must any brandy sold as brandy in the US, but EU rules allow brandy from 36%, and several European brandies are bottled at 38%. A 1.5 oz pour at 38% has 13.3 g of alcohol against 14 g at 40%.
Is cognac healthier than brandy? ▾
Not in any way that matters much. Calories are the same at the same strength, cognac's methanol cap is lower than the EU cap for brandy, and its measured sugar sat in the middle of the brandies we found. How much you drink and what you mix it with matter far more.
Can American brandy be called cognac? ▾
No. US rules reserve the name for grape brandy distilled in the Cognac region of France under French law, the same way Armagnac, Calvados and Brandy de Jerez belong to their regions.
Is armagnac a cognac? ▾
No. Armagnac is also French grape brandy, but from its own region of France under its own rules. The armagnac VSOP we found measured 6 g of sugar per liter, within the cognac range.
Is brandy gluten-free? ▾
Brandy is distilled from fruit, not from wheat, barley or rye, so no gluten grain goes into it. See gluten-free cognac.
More comparisons
Sources: 27 CFR 5.145, Brandy (US standards of identity), 27 CFR 5.155, Coloring, flavoring and blending materials, 27 CFR 5.72, Statements of coloring materials, 27 CFR 5.143, Whisky, Regulation (EU) 2019/787, Annex I (wine spirit, brandy, grape marc), Cahier des charges of the AOC Cognac, arrêté of 20 February 2025 (BO agri, 6 March 2025), Arrêté of 8 November 2018 amending the AOC Cognac specification (age terms), Swift and Davidson 1998, Alcohol hangover: mechanisms and mediators (NIAAA), Rohsenow et al. 2010, bourbon vs vodka hangovers, Jones 1987, Elimination half-life of methanol during hangover, Vinmonopolet 6301, Hennessy Very Special (40%, sugar 4 g/L), Vinmonopolet 1176401, Rémy Martin 1738 Accord Royal (40%, sugar 4 g/L), Vinmonopolet 764901, Rémy Martin Louis XIII (40%, sugar 5 g/L), Vinmonopolet 8001, Martell VSOP (40%, sugar 5.5 g/L), Vinmonopolet 7501, Martell VS (40%, sugar 6 g/L), Vinmonopolet 647901, Hine Rare V.S.O.P. (40%, sugar 8 g/L), Vinmonopolet 8801, Martell Cordon Bleu (40%, sugar 8 g/L), Vinmonopolet 11149501, Rémy Martin VSOP (40%, sugar 8.9 g/L), Vinmonopolet 5779401, Braastad Extra (40%, sugar 9 g/L), Vinmonopolet 7901, Hennessy V.S.O.P. (40%, sugar 9.8 g/L), Vinmonopolet 6201, Baron Otard VSOP (40%, sugar 10 g/L), Vinmonopolet 3045901, Hennessy Paradis (40%, sugar 10 g/L), Vinmonopolet 6901, Hennessy X.O. (40%, sugar 10.1 g/L), Vinmonopolet 20662001, Frapin Cognac VSOP (40%, sugar 11 g/L), Vinmonopolet 17379001, Delord Blanche d'Armagnac (42%, sugar under 3 g/L), Vinmonopolet 20305701, Dartigalongue Bas Armagnac VSOP (42%, sugar 6 g/L), Vinmonopolet 6392401, Carlos I (40%, sugar 12 g/L), Vinmonopolet 10068801, Lustau Brandy de Jerez Solera Gran Reserva (40%, sugar 25 g/L), Vinmonopolet 277901, Torres 10 Imperial Gran Reserva (38%, sugar 12 g/L), Vinmonopolet 3813101, Asbach Original Aged 3 Years (38%, sugar under 3 g/L), Vinmonopolet 4852201, Vecchia Romagna Etichetta Nera (38%, sugar 8 g/L), Vinmonopolet 3485301, Torres Pisco El Gobernador (40%, sugar under 3 g/L). SpiritFacts offers no medical advice.